Deacon John Tufts Mystery part two

Do you like a good mystery? Are you a genealogist or amateur researcher? I need help with this mystery of the shipwreck of Irish immigrants in 1737. In part one I told the story of Deacon John Tufts of Windham, New Hampshire and Belfast, Maine. http://tuftsgenealogy.blogspot.com/2012/10/here-is-my-first-attempt-at-article-on.html

What I seek now are similar stories in other families and any information on where these survivors settled when they were brought from Nova Scotia to New Hampshire or Massachusetts.

Deacon John Tufts (1723-1802) is debated to be either a son of a known family of the Peter Tufts clan of Massachusetts that I often write about, or a shipwreck survivor from Northern Ireland.

I recently discovered a news article that confirms a Mr. and Mrs. John Tuft perished in the shipwreck.

The shipwreck story is from a researcher and descendant who provided the transcription of Mary (Campbell) McMillan given to a family member and handed down through the family. Mary was said to be the granddaughter of “Jonathan Tuffs”. It describes the families settling Belfast, Maine, the shipwreck, and states that her grandfather was troubled by the sight of his mother dying in the shipwreck for all his years. The story can be found on some McMillan family trees on ancestry.com and at Patricia Thompson’s site: http://www.recordclick.com/stories-of-our-ancestors-the-lures-of-genealogical-research/

The father of Susanna Tuffs (wife of Dr. Alexander McMillan), whose name was Jonathan Tuffs, was born in Belfast, Ireland, and also of Scotch Covenanter blood. He started to this country with his widowed mother and her infant babe when he himself was fourteen years old. They were shipwrecked on the way. His mother, mother like, seeing that all could not be saved, gave her chance for life, also her purse and a God Speed in the New Country, should he reach it, to her son. The last he saw of her was when two pieces of the ship came together crushing her and her babe, then sank to rise no more. I have heard grandma tell how her father said that that was the last sight he saw when he closed his eyes and the ocean roar was always in his ears.

Jonathan Tuffs lived near what was afterwards Belfast, Maine and took up large tracts of land, giving the plot. of ground on which to build a town, which the people wanted to name for him, but he told them that was too (tuff) a name but if they must honor him thus they might name it for his native place, Belfast of Ireland, hence the tender interest every McMillan or Tuffs has in either place of that name.

Most historians and genealogists will admit that stories or legends handed down through generations are often inaccurate. There are some differences but the story appears to have a factual base.

There was a second version of the shipwreck story which was reported in Tufts Family History in 1964 by Jay Franklin Tufts. That was from a different branch of Deacon John Tufts’ descendants. Here is where I need help. That story was from the family of Deacon John’s son Joseph Tufts detailed here. If you are a descendant of this family please let me know if you have heard of this story.

JOSEPH5 TUFTS

b.  7, Aug. 1764 in Windham, N. H.

d. 16, July  1844 in Waterford, Pa.

married; in Londonderry, NH to SARAH DOAK, Sally   

dau of James and Janet (Boyes) Doak

b. 13, Nov. 1769 in Londonderry, NH, died? in Warsaw, N. Y.

had 1) Mary, 2) Sarah, 3) Sarah, 4) Catherine, 5) Aurella, 6) John. 7) Joseph, 8) Orpha, 9) Catherine, 10) Leman G.

The family of the son of Leman G Tufts below was said to be the source of the shipwreck story in Tufts Family History 1964.

CHARLES PIERCE TUFTS

b.   2, Aug. 1846 in Rushford, NY

d. 20, May  1922 in San Diego, CA

m. 29, Nov. 1880 in to EDITH MAE ELLS

dau of Alfred and Hannah Elizah (Palmer) Ells

b.   7, Mar. 1860 in Rockford, IL

d.   5, Dec. 1924 in San Diego, CA

had  1) Mamie C., 2) Annie L., 3) Patricia E. M., 4) Charles A., 5) Robert G.

This Robert G Tufts had a copy of the shipwreck story but the True descendants of his daughter Clarissa have never heard of it. Clarissa’s husband, William True was in the 101^st Airborne in WWII and was co-author of the book “The Cow Spoke French” which mentions Freeling Tufts Colt.

Without listing every little detail that may be inaccurate, I will present the basic and pertinent data and list some possible research areas that could solve this mystery or at least uncover the rest of this story.

It is clear from the recent news article discovery that a John Tuft originating in Ireland could have survived the shipwreck where his mother died.

Now that I have seen this new article I have searched harder for John Tuft. There are records of a Tuft family in Northern Ireland. Thomas Tuft was listed as a Presbyterian minister in Ballyclare in County Antrim from 1681-1713 and a John Tuft is listed as a linen draper in Derry in 1725. (http://lurgan-ancestry.co.uk/index.php/tenants-on-the-manor-of-brownlows-derry-1670-1799/)

Could this be our John? There are more records of Tuft families from later than 1737. A William Tuft is on the Hearth Tax list for County Armagh in 1664. In 1732 John Tuft was a Magheralin Parish Churchwarden (County Armagh, again). More research is needed.

The name issue is interesting. I have seen all variations of the name used. I have seen Tuft from the news article which could be wrong but led me to research and find the TUFT families in Ireland while so many searches have never discovered any John TUFTS. The name TUFFS was used in many of the Brookfield MA families.

 Herbert Adams searched extensively and paid researchers in Ireland to search as well. Professor James Hayden Tufts searched as well and found none. He was a descendant of the John TUFFS of Brookfield Massachusetts who the professor claimed was from Ireland. It would be interesting to know if the shipwreck story exists in his family. Adams originally stated John of Brookfield was married in Londonderry NH but changed that after further research to Newbury MA. (Some quotes of his 1975 Kinsmen edition can be found online.) Adams credits John’s family’s claims to Irish heritage as originating with John’s wife Agnes Foote who was said to be clearly Scots-Irish but no record of her can be found. Perhaps she also survived the shipwreck with no family and was absorbed into a Londonderry family until adulthood. There are records of Foote families in the other Ulster-Scot communities, but none of Agnes.

The John Tufts born in 1723 in Medford, MA is well recorded and researchers over the years have had different versions of his life. Some of the first thought he died young but Adams discovered his father’s will of 1725 which devised benefits to him through his Uncle Nathaniel Tufts. His mother remarried and died in Chelsea in 1760 leaving him named in her will as well. Adams claims this John moved to Windham, NH by 1745 and bought his cousin’s farm in 1752. The deed records I have found do not exactly confirm this. They can be found at http://www.nhdeeds.com/rockingham/RoHome.html

 1742      James Campbell sold to John Tufts of Londonderry land in Chester: “messuage or tract of land #116 in third division, 80 acres formerly of Jacob Gilman etc.. witnessed by Peter Tufts and Robert Boyes. It could be this Peter Tufts was a surveyor and/or just a witness or if this is John of Medford, he is in Londonderry but could be in the part that became Windham in 1742.

 1743      John Tuffts of Londonderry sold to Horner the same lot. He is clearly called John Tufts in the first deed and John Tuffts in the second and is called a “Labourer of Rec’d (record?) of Londonderry”. John made a profit of thirty pounds in one year of owning this land.

1744       Daniel Calfe (Calef) sold to John Tufts of Newbury, (Trader) 2 parcels in Chester 57 acres more or less.

1746       John Tufts of Newbury sold to Robert Calef, (quit claim deed) same parcels bought of his brother, Daniel. This john Tufts of Newbury could be Reverend John Tufts the son of Peter Jr. who left the church in 1738 and died in 1750 or John Tuffs/Tufts of Brookfield. He is called “of Newbury” by Kinsmen and said to have married Agnes Foote there in 1731 but I have not found that record.

1752       John Tufts of Charlestown (MA) sells 2 parcels of land in Bedford to a Robert Calef and secondly to Moses Barron. Research would be needed to see if these are 2 parcels which came to our John Tufts of Charlestown from his father’s estate which would clearly put him in Charlestown in 1745, not Windham.

1752       Jonathan Morrison sold to John Tufft of Windham, “2 pieces of meadow in Windham and bordered by Londonderry meadow, original right of Col. Tho’s Westbrook and Thomas Armstrong (13 acres)”. This is supposed to be the farm John bought from his cousin Ann but does not describe a home or farm. The deed describes the bounds of land with no mention of a mill or “messuage”. Jonathan Morison and Nancy (Ann) Tufts Morison had no children. They were married in 1741 and moved to Peterborough NH when they sold the farm to John. It would not be irregular for them to have taken young John into their home to work the farm but still does not answer which John that would be.

1754       James Reid sells to John Tufts of Windham and James Wilson meadow tract known as flat rock meadow.

1758       John Tufts of Frankfort (Maine) sells 2 lots in Bedford to 2 different Moore’s, Robert and Daniel. This is our Charlestown John’s cousin John, the son of Nathaniel Tufts.
1762       John Tuffts and James Wilson of Windham sell meadow tract called lower flat rock to John Morrow.

1774       John Tufft of Windham sold to James Gilmore 105 acres of upland in Windham (Bounded with flat rock meadow). The deed is signed by John and Mary Tufft.

1777       John Tufft of Belfast sells to James Gilmore 13 acres tract in Windham. These last 2 appear to be the sale of his farm or mill when he moved to Belfast ME. His mill operation is recorded in Windham history in 1755. He was a selectman there in 1752 and 1761. (History of WindhamNH) There is some confusion about exactly when he moved to Belfast. In researching his home in Belfast, researchers there feel he arrived after the Revolution and that his son built the home there they now consider the oldest home in Belfast. His son John, the ship’s captain of Newburyport, took some settlers and died young enough that his children were raised in Belfast. One trip is said to have run aground and damaged some goods including the Peter Tufts family bible.

These deed records could be researched more thoroughly. Some records of Nutfield/Londonderry NH reference Haverhill MA, as that town laid claim to parts of southern Rockingham County NH in that time period. There were also records of John Tufts of Bedford, NH but he was another second cousin from Newmarket, NH, the son of Henry (the tailor). It certainly seems some deeds are missing as John sold more land when he moved to Belfast than he is recorded as purchasing in previous records.

This Tufts family bible was said to be the convincing item that John of Belfast was from our Massachusetts family. I just cannot figure how Deacon John would have the bible of Peter Tufts if he was the survivor of the shipwreck.

                I have not been able to find the bible today. I have seen letters in Mr. Adams’ collection which describe it being destined for Tufts University and have contacted one person there with no result. The letter in Adams’ collection is from Christie (Tufts) Page and mentions the Tufts bible donation to Tufts University. She mentions in the letter a son Ted Page, grandson Charles Clifton Page and visiting with Glenn and Gladys.

“I have taken the liberty of sending your letter on to Glenn so she can locate the archivist at Tufts College and leave the Tufts Bible. I am sure she and her husband will be glad to deliver it.”

 Mr. Adams said they would probably just stuff it in an attic. It could be there in some library corner but their website does not state it is there. A field trip to the University is in order. The following pages of Adams Tufts Kinsmen newsletter show the bible story.

Where will the proof of either claim be found? Will it be in deed records or wills? Will it be in someone’s old diary in a library somewhere? Perhaps in some old file in a historical society in Windham or Londonderry. I had hopes John’s grave marker might say born in Ireland but even epitaphs can be incorrect and the stones in the cemetery he is probably in are not maintained. I would like to believe the shipwreck story and many people do. I see proof of that story in the news articles and the existence of the story in more than one family descended from John.

 Genealogists previous to me have worked hard to straighten out all the Johns but could certainly be mistaken. There are just too many Johns to be certain about. It is certainly possible that there were 2 Johns in Londonderry and Windham. There is also the possibility that the shipwreck survivor was brought up in Londonderry in another Ulster-Scot family like the Morison’s and later claimed he was from the “Boston” Tufts rather than admit to being Ulster-Scot as they were referred to as Irish and looked down upon. These “Scots-Irish” were called the worst kind of Irish….”Scottish”.

William Tuffs History or Mystery?

Was William Tuffs a Revolutionary soldier or just a storyteller? Was he from the Medford, Massachusetts TUFTS family or from another family? Was he even of Irish descent? 

I will present this story in two parts, the first about William’s service record and the second about his family.

Recently I received an inquiry about William Tuffs who passed away in Indiana in 1847. The local Daughters of the American Revolution chapter, which is named for William, is planning a 90^th anniversary and was looking any information about him. I knew the story of William and thought this would be an easy project on which to put some information together. How wrong I was. I am still trying to track down his story and would welcome any help anyone can give me.

William Tuffs (1750-1847) claims to have taken part in the Boston Tea Party, served in the Revolution, and the War of 1812. His grave in the Bonneyville cemetery in Bristol Indiana is marked by a large stone and has two plaques provided by the Improved Order of Red Men and the Sons of The American Revolution. 

He apparently loved to tell stories about his grand service.  The marker reads:  

“[He was] present at the battles of White Plains, Germantown, Lundy’s Lane, Monmouth and Bunker Hill and [was also] … present at the time of throwing overboard the tea at Boston.” (December 17, 1773) and served in the war of 1812 (at age 72).

In 1845 he related a story to a reporter of the Goshen Indiana Democrat of being captured from a privateer in the Revolution and carried to England as a prisoner. He also recounted being captured at the Battle of Ticonderoga and bearing a scar on his face from that battle. His tea party story was in the Democrat on December 17, 1840 as related to the editor Dr. E.W.H. Ellis. Perhaps his greatest tale was that he spent the winter at Valley Forge “joking with General Washington”. I have not seen the source of that story.

I have no problem believing any of his stories and trust that any skepticism would have been expressed at the time of telling. He surely could have exaggerated but without any proof that the stories are not true, I recognize his service and am proud of him. Soldiers like William are what have made our country great. A little exaggeration should be allowed an old patriot in his later years, as well as a few mistakes on details.

I am not the first person to research or believe this old soldier. There are several references I have used in my search for the truth, including the standard Tufts Kinsmen 2010 by Herbert Adams and the Tufts Kinsmen Association, William Tuffs Portrait of a Patriot by Carl Mauck, (a pamphlet written in recent years and held in the Elkhart library in Indiana), and The History of the Tuffs Family As Told in 1985 by Patricia Tuffs Snyder.  I also searched the usual online sources such as ancestry.com and some military records websites. I did not find any solid records confirming his military service, but feel they may be found.

The records that are available are his pension applications. They were made when he was in his 80s and are somewhat inversed in the timeline. The first application relates his later service and the second covers his early enlistments.

The first application is in September 1832 from Ohio but lists his service place as New York. The pension was rejected. At that time he was living in the township of Parkman, County Geauga, Ohio. This application is interesting because it details his testimony of service in much more detail than any of the newspaper articles or other stories. The rejection states his account is in variation with well known facts

“Say to the man that the whole narrative is to (too?) at variance with with well known facts ….? of this Dept. that his claim cannot be allowed-place the papers on file”

This testimony states:

Enlistment in the spring of 1776 from Albany NY in the company of Captain Cornelius Sanford in Col. Gansevoort’s Regiment and upon arrival at Fort George was sent to Skeenesborough to assist in building ships. He was assigned to the row galley Trumbull and fought (or dodged) the British fleet in battle on Lake Champlain. The ship escaped to Fort Ticonderoga and joined Benedict Arnold despite their Captain being killed in the action. This conflict is verifiable by simple historical research. On Wikipedia, I found the Trumbull listed as one of the row galleys in the action on Lake Champlain.

                     Tuffs’s narrative goes on to relate the action after evacuation of Ticonderoga and of and of his capture after the Trumbull was blown up. He escaped after one month and returned to his home in Mystic (Medford) near Boston. This was a common story in the guarded retreat from the Champlain Valley conflict. I recently read Rabble in Arms by Kenneth Roberts which describes incidents such as this in fictional but accurate detail.

His next statement of service is enlistment at Boston in Col. Jackson’s regiment where he marched to Rhode Island then crossed the Hudson at Kings Ferry and went to White Marsh New Jersey. This portion continues to tell about the winter of 1777-78 when he was employed as a teamster around Valley Forge until rejoining his unit at Philadelphia. After that his unit was in the Battle of Monmouth June 28, 1778. It was not uncommon for soldiers to return home after major battles. Some ended up listed as deserted, some returned to harvest crops, and for other reasons, but often, they returned to service in another company. In this period, I found variation of facts. Tuffs states they went to Long Island next when history records the regiment was at Staten Island and later at Rhode Island before taking winter quarters in 1778 near Morristown NJ. Col. Jackson’s regiment was called the 16^th or Jackson's Additional Continental Regiment and the history is well recorded. Francis Tufts was the Adjutant for this company. I would love to find out that he recorded William’s service but he was adjutant in 1780. Francis was promoted in the field after heroic action in battle (story to come).

After obtaining a furlough in May 1779 Tuffs returned home and signed on a privateer named Royal Empire and after early success was later captured and spent 7 months in Mill prison in England. He details that escapade more in his 1845 Democrat article I have been unable to find the records of the ships William recalls in his testimony about being a privateer and spending time at Mill prison in England. There are some names similar to his recollection but more research is required.

        William’s second application for pension is 1834 in Portage County Ohio. He states under oath that he was drafted in April 1775 in Capt. William Wentworth’s Company with Lt. John (?) serving the 3 month enlistment near Castle William in Boston harbor. He further testifies that he served in May 1776 in Capt Cornelius Sanford’s Company under Lt. Aldrich Vaughn carrying provisions across Lake George. I have found no record of a Captain William Wentworth. There was a Captain Wentworth Stewart (or Stuart) and many other Wentworths of Stoughton MA who served with Col. Gill. Benjamin Gill of Stoughton MA served his country proudly. He commanded the 3^rd Suffolk County Militia Regiment, which had service at Boston in 1776 and in the Saratoga campaign in 1777 which matches William’s testimony. It was disbanded in Dec. 1777 in Albany NY.

      Tuffs continues that he was released from that company in December or January in Albany, NY. He then describes how, in early summer 1777, he went out from Mystic in Captain Samuel Tucker’s company under Lt. Peter Smith, and was in the Battle of Rhode Island. If Tuffs had the dates and some of the names of his officers incorrect, this would explain why his testimony could not be matched to that of the officers he named. And if, when he was discharged from Col. Gill’s regiment, he joined up with the NY regiment of Col. Gansevoort, his record could be confirmed. It appears he made the mistake of confusing years 1776 and 1777.

If the dates were recalled incorrectly then his next assignment would have been with Col. Jackson’s regiment enlisting from Boston in 1778 and proceeding to NJ and Valley Forge, which matches historical records of the movements of Col. Jackson’s additional Continental Regiment (16th) as stated above.

        In conclusion William Tuffs made some errors in his testimony about his service but, as I stated before, he was over eighty years old when he made these reports. If he was incorrect in his dates and some of his officer’s names, he could have still served and his records might be found. His name was not listed in the Mason’s Lodge in Boston so Herb Adams insists in Tufts Kinsmen that William was probably not at the tea party. This does not mean he wasn’t and I hope to research this question further at the new Tea Party museum in Boston. A youth of his age (23 years old in 1773) in Boston certainly could have been involved in that protest and certainly would have turned out in April 1775 for the battles of Lexington and Concord, Bunker Hill, and the siege of Boston. Young men at this time mostly joined their own towns’ militias, so I wonder why William wasn’t among the nine Tufts minutemen of Medford. It is unknown why he took up with Captain Wentworth and to what regiment Captain Wentworth’s company was assigned in the action at Castle William in Boston Harbor. 

        If William’s next service was from Mystic in 1775, not 1776 in Captain Sanford’s company at Lake George, NY, I should be able to find the records of the correct regiment. Transporting provisions across Lake George would have been in support of the ill-fated attempt to capture Canada. Next William states that he was discharged at Albany, NY. If the correction of the years is assumed, it would make William’s first application statement correct in saying that he joined the NY regiment in 1777 and was also present in the Champlain Valley conflict. 

        From there on it is certainly a muddled record but if the regiments can be traced, William Tuffs would have followed the action in Col. Jackson’s regiment and maybe Captain Tucker and Lt. Smith can be found. The ships’ records may be even harder to find. A quick search came up empty for the names Royal Empire and Black Prince but there were some ships of the same name in different circumstances and the spelling as copied from the pension application is hard to decipher. The details stated in the newspaper article about his escape from the prison ship in New York are gripping and specific.

William’s claim of service in the war of 1812 are even harder to find. There are at least 2 William Tufts that served and one from Maine died in service. There are several resources for finding soldiers in this conflict. One is U.S. Army, Register of Enlistments, 1798-1914 in the National Archives. Another is Index to the Compiled Military Service Records for the Volunteer Soldiers Who Served During the War of 1812. Washington, D.C.: National Archives and Records Administration-M602, 234 rolls. It is difficult to assign to the correct persons but an attempt is made here.

This record of Enlistment shows the record of 3 William Tuffs/Tuffts/Tufts.

The first record; (William Tuffs) states on Roll at Fort Independence July 24 1814 and prisoner of war captured at Forty Mile Creek and arrived from Halifax under command of Capt. Geo. ? …discharged Aug 1814 term expired. Fort Independence was in Boston harbor, Forty Mile Creek was a battle around Stoney Creek Ontario. This subject is listed as 19 years old and certainly could not be William Tuffs as he claimed he was at the battle of Lundy’s Lane (near Niagara NY) at this same time.

The second record; (William Tufft), appears to state he was 39 years old from Medford enlisted at Utica NY but rejected and discharged.  This could be William but he would have had to disguise his age (72).

The third record; (William Tufts) states Captain Brookes Company Aug 1813,Return of dead and diseased men Sac.Har. NY (Sackets Harbor New York) Feb 17/1814 died in the service Sept 30/1813…unreadable. This may be the record of William from Belfast Maine, below as it matches his death date. No regiment is listed. (William Tufts of Belfast, Maine was born 14 May 1772 and died while in service in the War of 1812 on September 30, 1813. He was the son of John Tufts and Mary Campbell from Windham NH and Belfast, the subject of my shipwreck mystery story.)(http://tuftsgenealogy.blogspot.com/2012/10/here-is-my-first-attempt-at-article-on.html )

In conclusion, these records do not seem to confirm any service of William Tuffs, the subject of this story, but definitely leave clues for research.

There is certainly a lot of information contained in William’s tales to give me clues to find his actual record. I would love any suggestions about where to keep looking. The DAR chapter in Indiana would certainly like to correct the record as well. In part two of this story I will try and cover William’s ancestry. Kinsmen assigns him to the family of James Tuffs/Tufts of Medford and Piscataqua (Portsmouth NH) which is a family full of patriots and soldiers. Carl Mauck states that William’s father was John. Other TUFFS I have encountered in my research often include the possibility of Irish ancestors. Perhaps even the John Tuffs/Tufts of the shipwreck story or the Brookfield Massachusetts family who claim Irish ancestors. There were many descendants of William and others who have researched them, so I hope to have a full story in part two.